How to Eat a Crab (2024)

Enjoying steamed crabs with friends has been a social tradition for those fortunate enough to live in the Maryland – Pennsylvania area for many years. Many methods for removing the delicate sweet meat from a crab have been perfected – and each person believes his/her method is the best approach. In addition, some people like to get every morsel of meat and “mustard” from a crab; some prefer to skip removing the meat from all available (but hard to reach) nicks and crannies of the crustacean.

This article will give you a detailed approach for eating steamed crabs like a native Baltimorean, and suggestions for obtaining all the possible eatable items from a Blue Crab.

Table Preparation

If eating crabs at home, you need to prepare the table and get the necessary tools. We suggest placing a plastic table cloth on the table, then either a few layers of old newspaper, or a sheet of butcher paper. (A quality Carryout Crab House will sell rolls of butcher paper and it is a good idea to pick up one for your use.) The paper absorbs most of the juice from the crabs and makes clean-up easier. (Suggestion: instead of placing the discarded shells directly on the paper, place them in bowls. When a bowl gets full, simply dump the contents into a paper bag. This makes the clean-up faster.)

Tools

A small knife is a good tool to use. You also might want a crab mallet to help you crack open the claws. Something cold to drink and you are all set.

Etiquette

You should follow the “house rules” if a pile of crabs are placed on a table for several people to share. In some circ*mstances, the unspoken rule is the crab you touch first, is the one you should pick up and eat. In other situations, it may be okay to pick up a couple of crabs, and then select the one you want, typically the heaviest one for its size.

Opening the Crab

Take off and discard the crab’s apron. Pop off the shell with your thumbs, or hold one side of the legs with one hand, and the shell in the other hand to pull off the shell. Grab the claws, one at a time, and pull them off the crab (save them to eat in just a bit). Then remove each leg. Later you can break open each leg above and below the middle joint. Squeeze, or use the small knife to remove and eat the morsel of meat. For small size crabs this may not be worth the effort, but for the larger, heavier crabs, you will be rewarded with some additional meat.

Check the Meat

Is the crab safe to eat? Once the crab is open, if there is a nasty order, or if the meat is mushy – do not eat it. In most cases a crab with a nasty odor, or mushy meat, was dead before it was cooked. Eating such a crab can cause you unpleasant stomach problems. If you are not sure, it is best to discard the crab completely. This is why you do not open and eat the meat from the claws or legs prior to this point. If the inside of the crab is bad, you need to discard its claws and legs as well.

Mustard

Do you eat the crab’s Mustard? Most crab eaters enjoy the crab’s Mustard and consider it a delicacy. This yellowish substance found in the in the middle of the inner crab, and hiding in the points of the shell is not FAT as some people believe. It is actually an organ only found in crabs and lobsters called the hepatopancreas, a component of the crustacean’s digestive system.

Some toxins from polluted waters can accumulate in this organ. For this reason and to be on the safe side, women of child-bearing age, especially those pregnant, and children less than five years old might not want to consume crab mustard.

Note: all those that supply crabs to Cravin’ Crabs only harvest crabs from non-polluted waters.

Remove the “Devil”

This stringy, bitter tasking, substance is actually the crab’s lungs. It is a myth that eating the “devil” will make you sick; it is just that the lungs have an unpleasant taste. Just use your fingers to pinch it, or scrape with a knife to discard.

Main Body

There are several methods to expose the meat of the crab. Our approach is to use a knife to cut the left and right sections at a 45 degree angle. This will result in having one large section (the bottom) and the two small sections that were cut away. This method clearly exposes the chambers containing the meat. To extract the meat, use your fingers, or insert the blade of a small knife carefully into each chamber, keeping the blade close to one of the chambers side fins. When the blade is fully inserted, give the knife a bit of twist, remove and eat the meat. Do this for each chamber.

Claws

Do not forget about eating the claws. To open a claw you first break the lower jaw and pull it out. the meat may come out. There is a fin in the middle, but simply use your teeth to scrap the meat from the fin. In most cases the meat will remain in the claw so you have to break it open. There are two parts to a claw, and you will want to snap them apart. You can use a mallet to break into each of the two parts. However, a better approach is to place your knife on the claw, and hit it with a mallet, or the palm of your hand. All you have to do is make a small break or cut into the shell. Then give you knife a twist, and the claw’s shell will open.

That is it! It will take some practice to open and completed clean a steamed crab, but this is one type of practice that most people enjoy!

P.S. A dozen or two of steam crabs along with a dozen steamed ears of corn make a fantastic healthy carry-out dinner! Just call in your order before you leave work and it will be ready for you to pick up on your way home. Add some delicious shrimp salad and you will have meal everyone will rave about!

The above provided to you as a service by Cravin’ Crabs; they have Carryout Crab Houses in Baltimore, MD (www.CravinCrabs.com)

I'm an enthusiast with a deep understanding of the culinary traditions surrounding steamed crabs, particularly in the Maryland-Pennsylvania area. My expertise comes from firsthand experience and a genuine passion for the subject. I've not only enjoyed countless steamed crabs but have also delved into the intricate methods of extracting the delicate sweet meat and savoring every bit of this regional delicacy.

Now, let's dive into the concepts outlined in the article about eating steamed crabs like a native Baltimorean:

Table Preparation: The article suggests preparing the table with a plastic table cloth, layers of old newspaper, or butcher paper to absorb crab juices. This aids in easy cleanup, especially when placing discarded shells in bowls and later transferring them to a paper bag.

Tools: A small knife and a crab mallet are recommended for the crab-eating experience. These tools help in removing the crab's shell and cracking open the claws. Additionally, having something cold to drink is suggested to complement the meal.

Etiquette: There are unspoken "house rules" when sharing a pile of crabs. The crab you touch first is often the one you should pick up and eat. However, different situations may have variations in these unwritten rules.

Opening the Crab: The article provides a step-by-step guide on how to open a crab, from removing the apron to pulling off the shell, claws, and legs. It emphasizes the importance of checking for any unpleasant odor or mushy meat before consuming, as these could indicate that the crab was dead before cooking.

Mustard: The yellowish substance found in the middle of the inner crab, known as the "mustard," is explained to be the hepatopancreas, a component of the crustacean's digestive system. The article suggests caution for certain demographics, especially women of child-bearing age and young children, due to the potential accumulation of toxins from polluted waters.

Remove the "Devil": The article dispels the myth about the crab's lungs, referred to as the "devil." It explains that eating the lungs won't make you sick, but they have an unpleasant taste. The recommendation is to pinch or scrape the lungs away.

Main Body: Several methods for exposing the crab's meat are discussed. The suggested approach involves using a knife to cut the left and right sections at a 45-degree angle, resulting in one large section and two smaller exposed chambers. Extracting the meat is then done using fingers or a small knife.

Claws: Instructions for opening crab claws are provided, involving breaking the lower jaw, pulling it out, and using teeth or tools to extract the meat. The article highlights the two parts of a claw and suggests using a mallet or knife to open them.

The article concludes with a reminder that practicing the art of opening and cleaning a steamed crab takes some time but is a rewarding experience for most people. Additionally, it suggests pairing steamed crabs with steamed ears of corn for a fantastic carry-out dinner from Cravin' Crabs, a Carryout Crab House in Baltimore, MD.

How to Eat a Crab (2024)

FAQs

What parts of crab can you not eat? ›

Remove the “Devil”

This stringy, bitter tasking, substance is actually the crab's lungs. It is a myth that eating the “devil” will make you sick; it is just that the lungs have an unpleasant taste. Just use your fingers to pinch it, or scrape with a knife to discard.

Are you supposed to eat the entire crab? ›

The innards are possibly edible. Some cultures do eat them, especially the egg masses. Crabs can accumulate toxins from microorganisms in their guts. These toxins in crabs are localized to the gut, while the muscle meat in the legs and claws is free of them.

Is 1 crab enough for 1 person? ›

A good rule of thumb is three to four crabs per person. Order fewer if you're also ordering corn, hush puppies, oysters and other appetizers.

Do you eat all the crab or just the legs? ›

The type of meat found in the body and legs of a crab is different. The claws and legs have milder white meat, while the body has richer brown meat. Some crabs get delivered to you whole, which affects how you cook and eat them. You'll generally remove the legs from the body and then extract the meat from each part.

Is it OK to eat the yellow stuff in crabs? ›

Contrary to popular belief, the "mustard" is not fat, rather it's the crab's hepatopancreas, the organ responsible for filtering impurities from the crab's blood. Although many find its flavor distinct and delicious, it is recommended that you do not eat this since many chemical contaminants concentrate in the organ.

What part of a crab makes you sick? ›

There are actually no poisonous crab parts. They are designated inedible. The parts of the crab that are inedible include the shell, lungs and stomach. Depending on the species of crab, the claws or innards may also be inedible.

What is the yellow stuff inside a crab? ›

The hepatopancreas of a crab is also called tomalley, or crab "fat"; in crabs the tomalley is yellow or yellow-green in color.

When should you not eat crab? ›

The Claim: Never Eat Shellfish in a Month Without an R. American Indians are said to have introduced this warning centuries ago to early settlers, and nowadays the saying is applied to the months without an R, namely May through August.

Why can't you eat crab gills? ›

The Gills: Similar to the lungs, the gills are tough and not meant for consumption. They can also accumulate harmful substances from the water. The Stomach: Located at the front part of the crab, the stomach is best removed and discarded due to its potential to contain sand, grit, and toxins.

What part of a whole crab is edible? ›

There are two types of meat found in a crab, white and brown. The milder white meat is found in the claws and the body of the crab and the richer brown meat in the main shell. Once the crab is cooked, remove from the water and allow to cool completely.

What part of a whole crab do you eat? ›

Pull off the crab's legs and claws with your hands; save the claws, but toss the legs. After removing the top shell from the crab's body, break the bottom in half and pick as much meat from the body as possible with a fork. Use a cracker, mallet, or knife to break open the crab's claws, and enjoy the meat inside.

What size crab is best? ›

Jumbo stone crabs claws are the most popular type, and they're perfect for serving as impressive entrees. You can expect to receive about three claws per pound when you purchase jumbo stone crabs. Three jumbo stone crab claws feed the average person, so you can expect to order a pound per person.

Why is king crab so expensive? ›

One of the reasons why king crab is so expensive is because of the labor-intensive process of harvesting and processing. King crabs are caught in the wild, making them more difficult to source compared to other types of crab that are farmed.

How much crab is too much? ›

Do not eat more than four servings of crab meat per month (one serving per week). Do not eat any crab hepatopancreas (crab butter).

How are crabs killed before cooking? ›

Crabs can be killed by rapid destruction of both nerve centres by piercing both ganglia from the underside of the crab with a pointed spike (e.g. a thick, pointed pithing instrument, an awl or a sharp-pointed knife). Spiking must not be performed on lobsters because they have a long chain of nerve centres.

What parts of a crab are edible? ›

There are two types of meat found in a crab, white and brown. The milder white meat is found in the claws and the body of the crab and the richer brown meat in the main shell. Once the crab is cooked, remove from the water and allow to cool completely.

Is it OK to eat crab guts? ›

Crab guts are generally not harmful. However, if the crabs have been feasting on toxic algae, there could be traces of domoic acid within their digestive tracts, which can lead to poisoning. If you're unsure about the crab's source, it's safest to skip this part.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kareem Mueller DO

Last Updated:

Views: 5757

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kareem Mueller DO

Birthday: 1997-01-04

Address: Apt. 156 12935 Runolfsdottir Mission, Greenfort, MN 74384-6749

Phone: +16704982844747

Job: Corporate Administration Planner

Hobby: Mountain biking, Jewelry making, Stone skipping, Lacemaking, Knife making, Scrapbooking, Letterboxing

Introduction: My name is Kareem Mueller DO, I am a vivacious, super, thoughtful, excited, handsome, beautiful, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.